"SURPRISE" is about a guy who's psychic, a woman on the worst date of her life, and the best waiteress to ever work in a cheap, all-night diner. The psychic is Peter - but he's only psychic two minutes ahead. The best he can do is finish the sentences of his date, Whitney, who does not find this particularly amusing. Their waitress, Esther, has watched Peter get dumped by a multitude of women and she knows there are some things even a psychic can't see.